Who is Right or Wrong in Tokyo Ghoul: The Humans or the Ghouls?
Tokyo Ghoul presents a world where humans and ghouls struggle to coexist. Ghouls are supernatural beings who must consume human flesh to survive. This situation raises one big question: who is right and who is wrong, humans or ghouls?
The Human Perspective
Humans in Tokyo Ghoul live in a constant state of fear. Ghouls pose an existential threat because they must eat human flesh. To counter this threat, humans establish organizations like the CCG (Commission of Counter Ghoul). The CCG fights ghouls to protect human lives.
- Humans feel justified in defending themselves.
- Fear of ghouls is understandable given the deadly threat they pose.
- The loss of loved ones to ghouls fuels human anger and hatred.
Humans see the fight against ghouls as a fight for survival. They believe that eradicating ghouls is necessary to ensure safety. For many humans, there's no moral dilemma. It's kill or be killed.
The Ghoul Perspective
Ghouls, on the other hand, have no choice but to eat humans. They are not inherently evil; their biological needs drive their actions. Many ghouls wish they didn't have to harm humans. Some even try to coexist peacefully.
- Ghouls are born into their condition and can't change their nature.
- They face persecution and violence from humans.
- Some ghouls seek peaceful coexistence with humans, like Anteiku coffee shop members.
Ghouls' struggle for survival also leads them to form their own communities and families. These connections show they have similar emotional and social needs as humans. They are not mere monsters; they have depth and complexity.
Is There a Moral High Ground?
From a moral standpoint, declaring one side wholly right or wrong is complicated. The innocence of simple right and wrong does not apply here. Both humans and ghouls exhibit actions driven by the instinct to survive, protect loved ones, and ensure their future.
Reasons Why Humans Are Not Entirely Right
- Eradication campaigns against ghouls often involve innocent ghouls.
- Fear and hatred lead to extreme measures that can be morally questionable.
- Not all ghouls are predators; some are victims of circumstance.
Reasons Why Ghouls Are Not Entirely Wrong
- Ghouls have no choice but to eat human flesh.
- Many ghouls wish for peace and coexistence.
- Ghouls suffer greatly due to societal prejudice and violence.
Both humans and ghouls act out of a desire to survive. Each side has valid points and cannot solely be blamed. Ghouls should not be seen merely as monsters, and humans cannot be justified purely as defenders. The intricate blend of right and wrong heavily depends on actions taken by individuals within each group.
